Remodeling Your Bathroom? Here’s How to Decide Between a Shower and Tub

When it comes to choosing between a walk-in shower and a traditional tub for your bathroom, there are many factors to consider. This isn’t just about looks, it’s about lifestyle, comfort, budget, and even the future of your home. The bathroom is one of the most important spaces in a house, and the choice you make can change the way you use it every day.  

Benefits of Walk-In Showers

If you’re going for a sleek, modern look, a walk-in shower is a perfect choice. These showers instantly upgrade the style of your bathroom and can make the space feel more open and luxurious. Even in small bathrooms, a walk-in shower creates the illusion of more room. The clean lines, glass panels, and minimalist design often give a bathroom a spa-like feel, making everyday routines a little more enjoyable.

Another big perk? Walk-in showers are much easier to clean and maintain compared to tubs. With fewer corners and edges, there’s less chance for grime and soap scum to build up. Plus, most walk-in showers are designed with functionality in mind, think built-in shelving, benches, or even rainfall showerheads that bring a touch of luxury to your daily routine.

Accessibility is another important benefit. Walk-in showers are easy to enter and exit, making them a safe and convenient option for people of all ages. For homeowners thinking ahead about aging in place, this feature is a major selling point.

Benefits of Traditional Tubs

Who doesn’t love sinking into a warm bath at the end of a stressful day? Traditional tubs are perfect for relaxation. They’re also practical for families with young kids since bathtime is much easier (and safer) in a tub compared to a shower.

Another big advantage is home value. Real estate agents often recommend keeping at least one tub in the home because buyers, especially families, see them as essential. A bathroom with a tub can increase the overall appeal of your home when it comes time to sell.

And let’s not forget variety. From classic clawfoot tubs that add vintage charm to deep soaker tubs designed for luxury, there are many ways to make a bathtub the centerpiece of your bathroom. If creating a calming, retreat-like atmosphere is your goal, a traditional tub might be the right choice.

Factors to Consider

While both walk-in showers and traditional tubs have their perks, the right choice depends on your unique needs. Here are some important factors to think about before making your decision:

Lifestyle

Are you someone who prefers quick, energizing showers? Or do you love the idea of unwinding in a long soak? Daily showerers often benefit more from the convenience and efficiency of a walk-in shower. Bath enthusiasts, on the other hand, will appreciate having a tub available for relaxation.

Space

The size of your bathroom plays a huge role in this decision. In smaller bathrooms, a walk-in shower can maximize space and prevent the room from feeling cramped. For larger bathrooms, a tub fits in more comfortably and can even act as a focal point.

Budget

Cost is always an important factor in remodeling. Walk-in showers often require less material and can be more affordable to install, especially if you’re converting an old tub. That said, the overall cost depends on the finishes and features you choose. High-end shower systems or custom designs can push the budget higher, while basic tub replacements may be more cost-effective.

Future Needs

Think about your long-term plans. If you’re planning to stay in your home as you age, a walk-in shower with low or no threshold will be safer and easier to use. If you’re planning for children or even just thinking about resale value, it may be smart to keep a tub in the home.

Home Value

Speaking of resale, most experts recommend keeping at least one tub in homes with multiple bathrooms. That way, you don’t alienate potential buyers who see tubs as a must-have, while still enjoying the modern look and functionality of a walk-in shower in other spaces.

Best of Both Worlds

The good news is that you don’t always have to choose just one. There are ways to enjoy both a walk-in shower and a traditional tub, depending on your home layout.

Tub + Shower Combos

This option gives you the flexibility of both. You can take a quick shower during the week and still enjoy a long bath when you need it. For families, it’s also a practical solution since it works for everyone.

Two-Bathroom Strategy

If you have more than one bathroom, consider splitting the options. Install a walk-in shower in your primary bathroom for everyday convenience and luxury, and keep a traditional tub in a secondary bathroom for kids, guests, or resale value. This strategy allows you to enjoy the best of both without compromise.

Premier Home Pros’ Solutions

At Premier Home Pros, we make the remodeling process simple and stress-free. Our services are designed to give you the bathroom you want without the hassle.

- One-Day Shower Installations: Get a modern, functional shower installed quickly, so you can start enjoying it right away.

- Tub-to-Shower Conversions: Perfect for homeowners who are ready to upgrade from an outdated tub to a stylish, accessible walk-in shower.

- Walk-In Tubs: Ideal for safety, comfort, and relaxation, especially for aging homeowners or those with mobility concerns.

- Custom Engineered Stone Wall Surrounds: A durable and beautiful option for both showers and tubs, designed to look great and last for years.

Whether you want a spa-like walk-in shower, a cozy soaking tub, or the convenience of both, we have solutions to fit your needs.

Conclusion

The choice between a walk-in shower and a traditional tub depends on your lifestyle, space, budget, and future plans. Walk-in showers bring modern style, easy maintenance, and accessibility, while traditional tubs offer comfort, family-friendly convenience, and strong resale value. The best part is you don’t always have to pick just one, there are creative ways to combine both options in your home!

At the end of the day, your bathroom should work for you. Whether you want quick efficiency, long relaxation, or a mix of both, the right design can transform your daily routine and add value to your home. With Premier Home Pros, creating your dream bathroom is easier than ever. Schedule your free consultation today!

‍